Head-To-Head Of Two Fillet Knives

Comparing Smith’s Flex Fillet and Bear & Son Smooth White Bone Pro Fillet in fish-skinning dominance.

I was just about to type “fishing season is nearly upon us.” Living in Canada, it has never stopped. Up here, thousands of fishermen are manning their shanties, huddled over a hole, heaters blazing their favorite brand of barley pop nearby. Up north, fishing is a sport that runs year-round.

Why do men go ice fishing? Maybe they go for the love of it? Maybe the solitude and peace on the ice? Either way, they are out there. And certainly, a part of their kit is a good fillet knife. If you intend on eating some of what you catch, you need one. Which brings us to our topic.

We’ll head-to-head two fillet knives at opposite ends of the price spectrum. At the budget end is the Smith’s Flex Fillet Knife, and in the premium tier, the Bear & Son Smooth White Bone Professional Fillet Knife. Both knives have 7-inch-long blades, and both will be tested on some fresh catch from Lake Erie. Crossing my fingers, we get fillets for a meal.

A buddy of mine who is braver than I for facing the cold brought in a variety of pickerel (walleye for my American readers) and my favorite, yellow perch. Anyway, let’s talk knives. Some would figure that putting a $145 dollar knife up against a $20 isn’t a fair comparison. I would suggest that price sometimes doesn’t matter as much as value.

Tale Of The Tape

With a 7-inch blade, the Smith’s Flex has a mid-range flex to it. Beyond filleting fish, the author could see this stiffness making it a solid boning knife.
With a 7-inch blade, the Smith’s Flex has a mid-range flex to it. Beyond filleting fish, the author could see this stiffness making it a solid boning knife.
Given its thicker stock, the author found the White Smooth Bone’s blade on the stiff side. Out of the two blades, he could see this knife pulling duty cleaning game.
Given its thicker stock, the author found the White Smooth Bone’s blade on the stiff side. Out of the two blades, he could see this knife pulling duty cleaning game.

Handle ergonomics is important in a knife used for long periods of time. It is one thing to chop an onion and a completely different thing when you need to manipulate a blade to make detailed cuts repeatedly. Ergonomics on the Bear & Son are pretty good. The overall profile of the handle has the right contours. Out of the two, there is no doubt that the White Bone Professional has better looks with its split 25 percent black and 75 percent white handle scales. Part of the presentation of the handle is black liners that run into the black bolsters. Bear & Son use screws to fasten the scales to the full tang design. They also include a lanyard hole.

Smith’s, on the other hand, goes with a light injection-molded plastic handle. Unfortunately, they do not detail what material the handle is made from, and since do not play guessing games I will not hazard a misinformed guess. The molded handle on the Smith’s is lightweight. On the weight (without sheaths), the Bear & Son weighed in at 5.46 ounces, and the Smith’s weighed in at 2.98 ounces, according to my kitchen scale. Therefore, the Smith’s came in at almost half the heft. If you prefer a knife with a little heft to it, the Bear & Son is your model.

The author liked the Smith’s handle and found the design made the tip controllable for detailing jobs.
The author liked the Smith’s handle and found the design made the tip controllable for detailing jobs.

Sheaths for these knives are not a main area of concern, as a fillet knife isn’t generally meant for belt carry. You do want the blade protected. Naturally, you want to avoid holes in whatever you choose to tote your fishing gear in. Smith’s comes in a very minimal sheath, no belt loop and plenty of drainage holes, allowing the blade to dry. All those slots make sure the sheath is easy to wash out. The Professional comes with a sturdy molded sheath with various lashing points so you can attach it to your gear. Furthermore, it has a great friction lock-up. The only drawback to the Bear & Son sheath is a tiny drainage hole. This, however, is easily fixed with a large drill bit.

Fillet Fray

A good, sharp knife like the Smith’s Flex made it easy for the author to get clean fillets off the fish.
A good, sharp knife like the Smith’s Flex made it easy for the author to get clean fillets off the fish.

The Professional is made from 14C28N stainless steel, popular in fishing and fillet knives. The Smith’s is listed as a 400 series stainless steel, found in more budget-conscious blades—particularly kitchen cutlery. Despite the differences in materials, the Smith’s knife was sharp out of the box. The blade cleaned the fish with ease. We cut around the ribs to start, and, for the test, we cut through the ribs. Then, we deboned the fillets.

Next came the White Smooth Bone Professional. Right off, it needed work on its edge. Luckily, my friend had a draw-through type sharpener, and he touched up the edge. This improved the knife’s performance a bit, but it was still not optimal for the job at hand. Cutting through the ribs was more like breaking through them. Out-of-the-box sharpness, hands down, goes to the Smith’s Flex. In fact, we finished the rest of the haul with the knife, and it is still sharp enough to clean fish.

The author liked the Smooth White Bone Professional Fillet’s ergonomics and aesthetics. Once he upgraded the edge, it handled well and made easy work of its filleting tasks.
The author liked the Smooth White Bone Professional Fillet’s ergonomics and aesthetics. Once he upgraded the edge, it handled well and made easy work of its filleting tasks.

I will note that I worked on the Professional later after the test and did get the edge up to snuff, but it wasn’t there fresh from the box.

Final Cut

My final thoughts on the two are, for the money, the Smith’s probably gives a fisherman as much knife as most he’ll need. And it does so from the get-go. How will it perform long-term? I will have to do the hard work of going fishing to find out.

As for the Bear & Son? If you like the knife, you likely have to do some work to get its performance up. Please keep in mind that these are samples of one of each knife and may not hold true as a rule for either blade across the board. In the knifemaking process, the final step of putting an edge on the blade is mostly still done by hand. Whoever put the edge on the White Smooth Bone didn’t form it properly. Human error isn’t uncommon.

Either choice, good luck out there, and catch a bunch.

More Reviews:

Spycraft Knives SK-4 Sentinel Review: Covert Ringer

Spycraft Knives’ wharncliffe gives you an undercover edge.

Spycraft Knives is a new player in the game and offers some cloak-and-dagger in its design. As the company’s name suggests, its SK-4 Sentinel is designed with input from ex-SpecOps personnel and is designed for carry on your person or gear.

It’s a ringed knife with a handle shape that feels good in the hand and feels heavy in the hand. Its wharncliffe-shaped blade is a great all-around style, and the angled false edge slims the tip a little. It’s definitely a stout knife, but above all, it must cut. So, let’s run it through the basics.

Light-Duty Testing

Cardboard did curl, but the author didn’t chalk that up to issues with the knife’s hollow grind. Instead, it was more a factor of the knife’s thickness binding on cuts through the stiffer material.
Cardboard did curl, but the author didn’t chalk that up to issues with the knife’s hollow grind. Instead, it was more a factor of the knife’s thickness binding on cuts through the stiffer material.

Up first I tested the edge out of the box with paper slices. The SK-4 sliced fairly quickly with its factory edge and produced a clean cut on all but one attempt. I had a tear, but I put that on operator error as I caught the sharpening notch. Overall, the edge seems to have a medium grit finish designed for heavier work.

I moved on to single-walled cardboard with the Sentinel producing nice, clean cuts with plenty of curling. This was thanks to the knife’s hollow grind in its thick blade steel. It’s possible to get a bit of binding in certain materials with the blade, but it’s possible to push through it. Here, the edge was aggressive, and I had to make sure to keep my fingers clear and had a few close calls with shaving skin.

Through leather, the Sentinel was particularly aggressive, the author reports. Both cutting and skiving the hide were audible. Skiving was especially impressive, with the knife producing thin, uniform slices.
Through leather, the Sentinel was particularly aggressive, the author reports. Both cutting and skiving the hide were audible. Skiving was especially impressive, with the knife producing thin, uniform slices.

On to 8-ounce leather, the SK-4 was really aggressive. Slicing, I got a crunching sound with every cut and found the thumb notch helped keep the cuts evenly spaced. When I switched to skiving, the knife was still talking to me with every cut. Honestly, I didn’t feel any resistance when I was attacking the leather.

Heavy-Duty Testing

The knife had some nice attributes when challenging tougher materials, such as this pine. The author was able to exert more force when creating curly cues thanks to a smartly placed thumb notch on the spine.
The knife had some nice attributes when challenging tougher materials, such as this pine. The author was able to exert more force when creating curly cues thanks to a smartly placed thumb notch on the spine.

Pinewood was the SK-4’s next task and some whittling. I had to use a steeper angle because of the grind, but the knife produced very uniform curly cues for a fire stick. The contoured handles gave me plenty of control while making the longest cuts and thickest curly cues.

 I batoned the SK-4 into seasoned Hackberry wood. The first hit buried the blade, then I banged on the tip till the wood split. I tried holding the knife by the ring to give my hand room once the tip was buried. It worked, but I felt a lot of shock in my hand. Once the larger chunk of Hackberry was split, the SK-4 quickly split the thinner pieces. I found no noticeable damage to the edge, though it had a few wood smears to oil out.

The SK-4 was up to the tasks of splitting seasoned hackberry, however, it did leave the author with a sore hand when he tried to hold on to the ring while batoning.
The SK-4 was up to the tasks of splitting seasoned hackberry, however, it did leave the author with a sore hand when he tried to hold on to the ring while batoning.

Time for my favorite medium, sisal rope. The SK-4 crunched its way to 146 cuts before the edge started to slide. Nicely done. What was especially nice was that I found no hot spots on my hand from the handle. Overall, the wharncliffe blade aggressively zipped through the rope.

Overall Take

The SK-4 is a lot of knife in a smaller package. It has good edge retention with a comfortable handle. I am not a big fan of ringed knives, and I would like thinner steel used to keep weight down.

SK-4 Sentinel Specs
Maker: Spycraft Knives
Steel: K340 tool
Grind: Hollow
Overall Length: 9”
Blade Length: 4.09”
Weight: 7.26 ounces
Finish: PVD
Blade style: Wharncliffe
Handles: Textured G10
MSRP: $399

More Reviews:

Taking The Foot Path: Top Sheepsfoot Knives

Three unique sheepsfoot blades for top pocket performance.

A sheepsfoot blade hides its edge behind a quiet profile. It slices clean and never wanders. These three nowhere-near-a-kind blades remind you why the shape keeps earning loyal fans.

Sheepsfoot Advantage

A sheepsfoot blade shape delivers straight, predictable cuts without risk of a piercing tip. The sheepsfoot blade gets its name from its shape, which resembles a sheep’s hoof. The edge runs flat so the user can push through rope, cardboard and fabric with complete control. The dropped, rounded nose keeps the point out of the work, which helps during rescue tasks and close-quarters cutting. The shape shines in utility roles, but it trades away penetration and fine-tip detail work. Users who need a safe, steady cutter reach for a sheepsfoot. Users who need a sharp, probing point usually look elsewhere.

Reiff Knives Circadia

Taking it into the woods, the author found the Reiff Knives Circadian Sheepsfoot performed like a larger knife due to the full-sized handle and wide blade. The perfect tool for both the camp and kitchen.
Taking it into the woods, the author found the Reiff Knives Circadian Sheepsfoot performed like a larger knife due to the full-sized handle and wide blade. The perfect tool for both the camp and kitchen.

Reiff Knives built its reputation on hard-use tools designed for people who work and live outdoors. The Circadian Sheepsfoot fits that mission cleanly. Reiff Knives is a family run and veteran-owned company, and it’s carved out a niche by blending modern steels with field-driven ergonomics. Its knives aren’t showpieces—they’re workhorses built to survive real use in the backcountry, the shop or the boat. The Circadian line has been one of the company’s best sellers, and the sheepsfoot variant pushes the platform into pure utility.

The Circadian Sheepsfoot features a compact EDC profile, measuring roughly 7 inches in overall length, depending on the sheath and scale configuration. The blade measures about 3 inches and is cut from CPM MagnaCut, a steel chosen for its balance of toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance—a smart match for a knife meant to live outdoors. Reiff offers the blade in stonewash or black DLC, both finishes built for durability and low glare. The 90-degree spine is sharp enough to spark from a ferro rod, adding value for fieldcraft.

Handle scales are available in canvas Micarta, colored black or green depending on the model. The geometry favors control: a deep index cut, a neutral mid-section and a palm swell that locks the hand without forcing a grip. It’s a compact knife that still feels anchored during push cuts, rope work and fine carving.

Reiff pairs the Circadian Sheepsfoot with a Kydex sheath, sold in multiple colors and patterns, including black, OD green and multicam. Reiff designed the sheath for belt or pack-strap carry with enough retention for active movement. It’s an EDC fixed blade—small enough for daily tasks and tough enough for field abuse.

Circadian Sheepsfoot Specs
Overall Length: 7.25”
Blade Length: 3.28”
Blade Thickness: 0.120
Steel: CPM-MagnaCut Stainless
Finish: Stonewash
Weight: 4.10 oz.
Scales: OD Green Canvas Micarta
Sheath: Ambidextrous Universal Kydex with Tek-Lok
Made in the U.S.A.
MSRP: $285

Circadian Performance

Sheepsfoot blades excel in the kitchen, similar to a santoku knife with a flat blade. The Circadian slices with authority, performing pull slices with the tip.
Sheepsfoot blades excel in the kitchen, similar to a santoku knife with a flat blade. The Circadian slices with authority, performing pull slices with the tip.

Even though these three knives are in the EDC realm, the Circadian Sheepsfoot feels like the big brother. I have to give comfort and solidness to it. The knife has the heft to baton wood for the dry parts, and the edge geometry to feather wood like an ordained bushcraft knife. On top of that, the 90-degree spine showered sparks on every part, even the jimping.

It acts like a mini santoku knife in the woods, cabin and home kitchen. It performs draw cuts like a champ on food, cardboard, cordage, paper and leather. I made it my woods sheepsfoot blade and relied on it solo and teamed up with a chopper/splitter in the winter months. I touched up the MagnaCut blade once while testing it, and it wasn’t a chore, because I never let it get dull enough to need the sharpening stone.

I added an UltiClip to the sheath, carried it in my utility pocket and called it good!
The Circadian Sheepsfoot delivers reliable cutting performance for those who need a dependable tool that never falters. It’s simple, rugged and purpose-driven—exactly what Reiff Knives promises with every tool they ship!

Bear & Son Culery Large Sheepfoot Barlow

Bear & Son blends tradition with Alabama craftsmanship in the Large Sheepfoot Barlow, featuring simple mechanics and quality materials. Even living up to modern performance expectations, the author found the stag handle gave it “old-timey” appeal.
Bear & Son blends tradition with Alabama craftsmanship in the Large Sheepfoot Barlow, featuring simple mechanics and quality materials. Even living up to modern performance expectations, the author found the stag handle gave it “old-timey” appeal.

Bear & Son Cutlery operates out of Jacksonville, Alabama, where it machines, grinds, assembles and sharpens every knife under one roof. That full-control approach gives its traditional patterns a level of consistency collectors and working users both appreciate. The Large Sheepfoot Barlow sits squarely in that tradition. It blends a classic American pattern with modern steel choices and multiple handle options, giving the user a pocket tool that feels familiar but performs with modern reliability.

The knife measures 7 inches in overall length and 4 inches closed. Bear & Son fits the frame with a 2.75-inch sheepsfoot blade cut from stainless steel. The second blade mirrors a traditional Barlow layout, providing a backup edge for finer work. The sheepsfoot profile drives straight cuts through rope, cardboard and daily tasks with predictable control. The company shapes the spine with a clean, squared feel, which helps during controlled push cuts and scraping chores.

Handle options include rosewood, Genuine India Stag Bone and white smooth bone. Each material gives the knife a different personality: rosewood for warmth, stag for texture and smooth bone for a classic pocket-worn look. Nickel-silver bolsters anchor the Barlow silhouette and add durability at the pivot.

The knife is a slipjoint, so it stays legal in most jurisdictions and fits the traditional-carry crowd. Bear & Son ships it without a sheath, as expected for a pocket Barlow. The weight lands at 3.7 ounces, which keeps it planted in the pocket without feeling bulky.

2-Blade Barlow Sheepsfoot
Overall Length: 7”
Blade Length: 3”
Closed: 4”
Blade Thickness: 0.90″
Steel: Stainless
Finish: Satin
Weight: 2.9 oz.
Scales: Rosewood, Genuine India Stag Bone, White Smooth Bone
Sheath: None
Made in the U.S.A.
MSRP: $79

Large Sheepfoot Barlow Performance

The Sheepfoot Barlow's large blade cut through leather and nylon webbing easily. Meanwhile, the comfortable, tapered handle made pull slicing smooth.
The Sheepfoot Barlow’s large blade cut through leather and nylon webbing easily. Meanwhile, the comfortable, tapered handle made pull slicing smooth.

The Large Sheepfoot Barlow had some weight and an old-timey impression. It made me feel classy when I used it and it sliced like a champ. Its solid feel was substantial, though I took extra care when pulling the blades out. The liners inside the handles were sharp—near paper-cut sharp. But I didn’t draw blood when I opened it. They were just rough to the touch.

Both blades were wicked sharp. The smaller blade had a more awl-like shape and was thick enough to use as one. Or it could be your up-close, carving-in-tight-places blade. Pick your poison. The main blade excels at slicing rope, and the sharp tip makes short work of leather. What surprised me most was how detailed the sheepsfoot was mincing fresh garlic in the kitchen. Naturally, the stainless steel remained worry-free around moisture.

Bear & Son continues to push traditional patterns forward while keeping the work in Alabama. The Large Sheepfoot Barlow reflects that mission: simple mechanics, honest materials and a pattern that earned its place over generations.

Tactile Knife Co. Redhawk

Kept to the company’s tight tolerances, the Tactile Knife Co. Redhawk is a versatile cutter designed for everyday use—indoors or outdoors. The author found the knife’s design and build quality impeccable.
Kept to the company’s tight tolerances, the Tactile Knife Co. Redhawk is a versatile cutter designed for everyday use—indoors or outdoors. The author found the knife’s design and build quality impeccable.

The Redhawk marks Tactile Knife Co.’s push into the compact fixed-blade EDC space, and it carries the same machining pedigree that put the Dallas-based shop on the map. Tactile started as a precision pen company before expanding into knives, but its through-line never changed: tight tolerances, clean lines and American-made materials. Its shop in Texas machines nearly every component in-house, and the company leans hard into heirloom-grade build quality. The Redhawk reflects that ethos—simple, durable and purpose-driven.

Taylor Martin created the Redhawk after years of carrying fixed blades that fell short. It’s a compact knife punching above its size without feeling delicate. It measures just under 7 inches in overall length (6.9 inches OAL) with a 2.75- or 3-inch blade, depending on the variant. The blade, cut from CPM MagnaCut, is a steel chosen for its balance of toughness, edge retention and corrosion resistance. Its reverse tanto/modified sheepsfoot profile gives it a tall cutting surface and a fine, workable tip. Blade stock runs 0.12-inch, keeping it slicey without feeling thin.

Handle scales are made of Micarta and come in multiple colors. Tactile shaped them with a scalloped pinch-grip area for control during fine work and heavy cuts using a chest-lever grip. Finish options include stonewashed, tumbled Cerakote and black Cerakote, depending on the retailer. The spine is ground clean and crisp, suitable for scraping tinder or striking a ferro rod. Tactile doesn’t explicitly market it as a 90-degree spine, but it behaves like one in use.

The knife ships with either a Kydex or leather sheath, both set up for pocket carry with a clip, making it a true EDC fixed blade rather than a belt-only option.

Redhawk Specs
Designer: Taylor Martin
Overall Length: 6.9”
Blade Length: 2.75”
Blade Thickness: 0.120
Steel: CPM-MagnaCut Stainless
Finish: Cerakote (black)
Weight: 3.16 oz.
Scales: 3D Contoured Micarta Handles (black)
Sheath: Kydex Discreet Carry Concepts Sheath Clip
Made in the U.S.A.
MSRP: $249

Redhawk Performance

The Redhawk was a woods camp breakfast companion during the author’s testing. The sheepsfoot both helped with fire, food prep and eating.
The Redhawk was a woods camp breakfast companion during the author’s testing. The sheepsfoot both helped with fire, food prep and eating.

I first saw the Redhawk in Taylor Martin’s hand at an outdoor event. We talked about it later that evening, and I was eager to get one and put it through the wringer. First stop—the Irish pub to show the guys. After show-and-tell, it was nearing the holiday season and the Redhawk went to work on package duty. Work included heavy plastic strapping, paper and plastic packaging, bubble wrapping and—as little as possible—tape. I hate sticky blades, so usually I cut through cardboard when breaking them down flat. Believe it or not, paper, grass and cardboard are all hard on an edge.

In the woods, the Redhawk made feather sticks for a fire from wet wood and went on to slice ham and sausages. It kept a small bio stove well fed in the colder end of autumn. The blade performed as expected—well! The handle was nimble, yet substantially comfortable. The scalloped grooves in the Micarta scales did their job, especially in chest-lever and pinch grips.

The Redhawk is a compact cutter built for daily tasks, but it carries the machining DNA of a much larger knife. It’s a minimalist tool with maximum intent—exactly what Tactile Knife Co. set out to build.

Closing

The sheepsfoot blade shape shares genetic material with many knives, such as the Malaysian parang, the Japanese santoku knife, rescue knives and Serbian-style cleavers. There’s no escaping this timeless pattern!

Knife Reviews:

Aaron Wilburn’s BodyGuard Review: Cutting At Another Level

Aaron Wilburn’s BodyGuard pushes the performance bounds of a hard-work knife.

ABS master smith Aaron Wilburn produces spot-on precision works of art. His mosaic damascus is gorgeous, yet he still likes to make hard-working blades. The BodyGuard is one of the latter. It’s no frills, just tuned 52100 steel and textured non-slip Micarta handles.

A lot of knowledge is poured into these heavy-duty knives. It’s a little on the larger side for an EDC, but once in your hand, it’s very hard to use anything else. I’m all about the feel of a knife in your hand and the sharpness of its blade. Aaron’s BodyGuard is spot on in both fields. So, let’s get to cutting with the BodyGuard.

Skiving 8-ounce leather, the author found the slight curve to the belly of the knife let him roll rapidly into each thin slice.
Skiving 8-ounce leather, the author found the slight curve to the belly of the knife let him roll rapidly into each thin slice.

To start, I executed a simple slice of paper to check the fresh edge. The BodyGuard sheared smoothly and quickly, with the edge showing itself on the aggressive side, meaning you could hear each slice. I had to move fast with my fingers so no nicks would occur. The knife’s balance felt correct while cutting.

Next, I was on to some single-walled cardboard. The BodyGuard was slicing so fast and so sharply that none of the cuts distorted the cardboard. This is due to its full flat grind. The Cerekote coating helped, as well, reducing drag. Once more, the edge was notably audible and forceful through the material.

The BodyGuard’s plunge lines were spot on, uniform in depth and angle. This is always a sure sign of a well-made knife.
The BodyGuard’s plunge lines were spot on, uniform in depth and angle. This is always a sure sign of a well-made knife.

I pulled some scrap 8-ounce leather to skive. The BodyGuard made quick work of it. The slight curve to the belly of the knife let me roll rapidly into each thin slice. It was a fast enough pace that I managed to put a nick in my fingernail. The textured canvas handles proved very grippy and had a comfortable feeling. With the leather on its edge, I made more cuts, happily segmenting it without removing any of my flesh. Each cut gave me a nice crunching sound. Very sharp edge.

Laying The Wood

Using a leftover piece of pine, I did some whittling for a firestick. I ended up with thin curlicues and thick curlicue. All cuts were smooth, like they were from a carving tool. Its handle provided a positive grip on this more challenging medium and ensured smooth cuts. The finish took some wood smears, as expected, but the edge was still like a razor.

The BodyGuard was no hack in testing its edge against whitetail deer antler. The author littered his shop with antler fragments, however, the knife’s edge remained pristine.
The BodyGuard was no hack in testing its edge against whitetail deer antler. The author littered his shop with antler fragments, however, the knife’s edge remained pristine.

Subsequently, I gave the BodyGuard a beating or I should say a batoning. Using a piece of seasoned hackberry, I batoned the blade into it to split some kindling. I found the false edge was ground almost too sharply; it wanted to stick into the baton piece of wood on the first two whacks. No issues after that with the BodyGuard making short work of the chunk of hackberry. I did notice the ends of the handles were a little sharp on the inside of my palm during this exercise. A few wipes of 400-grit sandpaper removed the edge. Again, more wood smears on the Cerakote, but the coating was 100 percent attached. Excellent job.

After some hard material, I tested the knife’s edge retention on 1/2-inch sisal rope. Man, does the BodyGuard cut, crunching through 200 cuts of the rope in record time. The edge felt like it was getting sharper with every slash. Even after all that, the knife remained extremely sharp.

The BodyGuard was no hack in testing its edge against whitetail deer antler. The author littered his shop with antler fragments, however, the knife’s edge remained pristine.
The BodyGuard was no hack in testing its edge against whitetail deer antler. The author littered his shop with antler fragments, however, the knife’s edge remained pristine.

Finally, it was time to get busy on a whitetail deer antler with 30 hard whacks. All that did was send antler chunks all over my shop without even a micro nick on the edge. That demonstrated excellent heat treatment. And the edge still felt razor sharp.

The last step was to retest the edge on paper. The BodyGuard seemed to slice even faster after all its use. Smooth cuts through the 20-pound-bonded with no tear outs. Enough said and cut.

Bottom Line

I just make a minor softening on the end of the handle. Otherwise, the BodyGuard from Aaron Wilburn is in the top 1 percent of the knives I’ve tested. It will handle civilian, hunters and military chores with ease. Hats off to the maker.

More Reviews:

Homefront Hot: New American-Made Knives For 2026

The latest American-made factory knives are sharp and sweet.


Reiff Knives Rangewolf

USA Reiff-RangeWolf_Awaken-Outdoors

Knife type: A lightweight, compact utility model for hunting and EDC
Designer: Stu Shank
Blade length: 3”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Full flat
Blade finish: Stonewash
Blade pattern: Drop point
Handle material: G-10 or canvas Micarta®
Handle material options: Black & orange G-10, black G-10, OD green G-10, green canvas Micarta, black canvas Micarta
Weight: 4.5 ozs. w/G-10, 3.9 ozs. w/canvas Micarta
Overall length: 7.12”
Special features: Full spine gimping along 3/4 of the blade; gimped ramp on front of scales for pinch grip; textured, ergonomic handle for secure, comfortable use; recessed lanyard hole; gimping fore and aft of handle for added grip
Sheath: Leather pocket model w/UltiClip (2 leather options); leather scout carry belt model (2 leather options); Kydex model w/2x IWB Pull-the-DOT belt loops
MSRP: $325
Available: NOW


Kershaw Bareknuckle Duralock

Kershaw Bareknuckle Duralock

Knife type: EDC folder
Designer: Kershaw original
Blade length: 3.5”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Blade finish: Black PVD
Handle material: Aluminum 
Weight: 3.4 ozs.
Lock type: DuraLock
Pocket clip: Reversible, extra-deep carry 
Closed length: 4.74”
Special features: Manual folder blade pivots on KVT ballbearings
MSRP: $269.99
Available: NOW


Boker USA Backcountry

Boker USA Backcountry

Knife type: Fixed blade
Blade length: 3.6”
Blade steel: 154CM stainless
Blade @the thickest: 0.09”
Blade finish: Horizontally brushed
Blade pattern: Drop point
Construction: Full tang
Handle material: Black G-10
Weight: 2 ozs.
Overall length: 7.5”
Sheath: Black Kydex
MSRP: $199.95
Knife to know: The Backcountry is the first Boker knife made on American soil since 1945; detailed gimping at blade spine and near the tip; includes hole for a lanyard
Available: NOW

Boker USA Backcountry Fixed Blade Knife Orange G-10 02BU0001

Boker USA Backcountry Fixed Blade Knife Orange G-10 02BU0001

$199.75
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Toor Knives Dropwing

Toor Knives Dropwing

Knife type: EDC/tactical folder
Blade length: 3.5”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Rockwell hardness: 61-63 HRC
Blade @the thickest: .136”
Blade finish: Black KG Gunkote
Pivot action: Phosphorous bronze washer
Handle material: Tan G-10
Lock type: Crosslock
Pocket clip: Titanium
Hardware: Titanium
Weight: 4.6 ozs.
Closed length: 4.625”
MSRP: $350
Available: NOW

Toor Knives Dropwing

Toor Knives Dropwing

$350.00
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Montana Knife Co. Wargoat

Montana Knife Co. Wargoat

Knife type: Tactical fixed blade
Designer: MKC in-house
Blade length: 3.75”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Full flat
Blade finish: Cerakote®
Blade pattern: Trailing point
Handle material: G-10
Weight: 2.23 ozs.
Overall length: 8”
Special features: Index ring
Sheath: Kydex w/UltiClip
MSRP: $325
Available: February 2026


Tactile Knife Co. Mariner 2

Tactile Knife Co. Mariner 2

Knife type: EDC folder
Designer: BLADE Magazine Cutlery Hall-of-Fame® member Bob Terzuola
Blade length: 3”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Flat
Blade finish: Stonewashed
Blade pattern: Sheepsfoot
Handle material: Titanium 
Handle material options: Vintage Micarta® and G-10
Weight: 3.6 ozs.
Lock type: Inset linerlock
Pocket clip: Milled ti
Closed length: 4.175”
Knife to know: Dovetailed thumb disc & shelved liner
MSRP: $429
Available: NOW


Heretic Knives Kobold

Heretic Knives Kobold

Knife type: Pocket fixed blade
Designer: Anthony Marfione Jr
Blade length: 2.5”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade material options: Will be available in Magnamax steel starting with the tanto pattern in 2026
Blade pattern: Bowie
Blade finish: DLC
Handle material: G-10; also available in carbon fiber
Overall length: 6”
Special features: Pressed G-10 scales available in different colors; comes w/lanyard
Sheath: Leather by JRE Industries w/reversible UltiClip
MSRP: Starting at $265
Available: NOW

Heretic Knives Kobold Fixed Blade Knife G-10

Heretic Knives Kobold Fixed Blade Knife G-10

$265.00
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Hogue K365A

Hogue K365A

Knife type: EDC automatic
Designer: Bruhns Design
Blade length: 2.75”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: High grind profile; hand-honed edge
Blade @the thickest: 0.115”
Blade finish: Coyote tan PVD or black Cerakote®
Blade pattern: Clip point
Handle material: Polyamide Nylon 12
Color options: Coyote tan, grey or solid black frame
Weight: 2.4 ozs.
Lock type: Push button
Pocket clip type: Deep carry w/filler plate (right or left)
Closed length: 4”
MSRP: $184.95
Available: NOW


CRKT M16-03 Bali

CRKT M16-03 Bali

Designer: BLADE Magazine Cutlery Hall-of-Fame® member Kit Carson    
Blade length: 3.38” 
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Flat
Blade finish: Stonewash
Blade pattern: Drop point
Handle material: Titanium
Lock type: Locking latch for opening and closing
Pocket clip: Titanium; removable
Weight: 2.5 ozs.
Closed length: 4.51” 
Special features: IKBS ball bearing pivot
MSRP: $300
Available: NOW


McNees Knives MAC2 3″

McNees Knives MAC2 3"

Knife type: Tactical folder
Designer: Jonathan McNees
Blade length: 3”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: High-performance hollow
Blade finish: Satin stonewashed
Blade pattern: Drop point
Handle material: Titanium
Lock type: Reeve Integral Lock
Pocket clip: Bent titanium
Hardware: Titanium
Weight: 3.3 ozs.
Closed length: 3 5/8”
MSRP: $498
Available: NOW


Vero Engineering Phase

Vero Engineering Phase

Knife type: EDC fixed blade
Designer: Joseph Vero
Blade length: 2.6”
Blade steel: Nitro-V stainless
Blade finish: Stonewash
Handle material: Titanium
Weight: 1.9 ozs.
Overall length: 6.75”
Special features: Interchangeable-blade system
Sheath: Kydex
MSRP: $318
Available: 2026


Big Idea Design Lookout

Big Idea Design Lookout

Knife type: EDC fixed blade
Designer: Big Idea Design
Blade length: 2.2”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Flat 
Blade finish: Stonewash
Blade pattern: Clip point
Handle material: Titanium 
Handle material options: G-10, natural Micarta®, titanium
Weight: 2.29 ozs.
Overall length: 6.2”
Special features: Through-hole hardware
Sheath: Kydex, left and right
MSRP: $275 (titanium) & $250 (G-10 and Micarta)
Available: NOW

Big Idea Design Lookout Fixed Blade Knife

Big Idea Design Lookout Fixed Blade Knife

$200.00
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Utica Cutlery Disruption IV

Utica Cutlery Disruption IV

Knife type: EDC folder
Designer: Utica Cutlery
Blade length: 3.25”
Blade material: D2 tool steel
Blade grind: Flat
Blade finish: Stonewashed
Blade pattern: Spear
Handle material: G-10
Lock type: Button lock
Pocket clip: Multi-location, standard
Weight: 4.1 ozs
Closed length: 4.5”
MSRP: $75
Available: NOW


Bear & Son Cutlery Lawman

Bear & Son Cutlery Lawman

Full model name: 4 3/8” White Smooth Bone Handle w/Carbon Fiber Bolster Lawman
Knife type: EDC folder
Designer: Bear & Son Cutlery
Blade length: 3.25”
Blade material: D2 tool steel (also available in damascus)
Blade grind: Taper (flat)
Blade finish: Satin
Blade pattern: Drop point
Handle material: White smooth bone & carbon fiber
Lock type: Slide lock
Pocket clip material: Steel
Weight: 3.5 ozs.
Closed length: 4.62”
Special features: Ball bearing washers
MSRP: $123.99
Available: NOW


Bradford USA Guardian 3.5 XL

Rick Hinderer Knives

Knife type: EDC fixed blade
Designer: Bradford Knives
Blade length: 4”
Blade steel: AEB-L stainless
Blade grind: Sabre
Blade finish options: Stonewash, nimbus or black DLC
Handle material options: G-10, carbon fiber or Micarta®
Weight: 4.7 ozs.
Overall length: 8.25”
Sheath: New vertical and horizontal model
MSRP: $199
Available: NOW


Winkler Knives WK Belt Knife

Winkler Knives WK Belt Knife

Knife type: Outdoor/tactical fixed blade
Designer: BLADE Magazine Cutlery Hall-of-Fame® member Daniel Winkler
Blade length: 4.5”
Blade material: 80CrV2 carbon steel
Blade grind: Flat w/false edge
Blade finish: No-glare black oxide
Blade pattern: Trailing point
Handle material options: Walnut (pictured); black, brown, green & black, & natural (WASP); G-10 camo; maple
Weight: Varies based on handle material; as pictured 7.2 ozs.; as pictured plus sheath, 11.4 ozs.
Overall length: 9”
Special features: Full tapered tang, thumb index filework
Sheath options: Lined Boltaron® w/leather cover; black leather w/synthetic-handle knives; brown leather w/wood-handle knives; clip system facilitates multiple carry options/positions; Discreet Carry Concepts: spring steel belt clip (Monoblock)
MSRP: $350
Available: Select configurations currently available; all others available for order (2-3 month turnaround)


Rick Hinderer Knives XM-18 3.5″ Bowie

Rick Hinderer Knives XM-18 3.5" Bowie

Full name of knife: Aluminum Automatic XM-18 3.5” Bowie 
Knife type: EDC folder
Designer: Rick Hinderer
Blade length: 3.5”
Blade steel: S45VN stainless
Blade finish: Stonewash
Handle material: Aluminum-orange w/Lava Flow FCF inlay
Weight: 5.12 ozs.
Lock type: Button lock
Closed length: 4.75”
Special features: The titanium half liners are patent pending
MSRP: $475
Available: Spring 2026


Chris Reeve Knives Backpacker

Chris Reeve Knives Backpacker

Knife type: Outdoors
Designer: Chris Reeve Knives
Blade length: 4.019”
Blade steel: CPM MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Hollow
Blade finish: Stonewashed
Handle material: Canvas Micarta®
Handle material options: Black or natural canvas Micarta
Weight: 3.8 ozs.
Overall length: 8.527”
Special features: Drop-point-shaped blade w/ample belly; scales may be removed for extra-lightweight use 
Sheath: Kydex
MSRP: $300
Available: NOW


Spyderco Para Military 2 Lightweight

Spyderco Para Military 2 Lightweight

Model number: C81PBK2
Knife type: EDC folder
Designers: BLADE Magazine Cutlery Hall-of-Fame® member Sal Glesser & Eric Glesser
Blade length: 3.47”
Blade steel: CTS® BD1N stainless
Blade grind: Full flat
Blade finish: Satin
Blade pattern: Modified clip point
Handle material: FRN
Weight: 2.8 ozs.
Lock type: Compression Lock®
Pocket clip: Metal
Closed length: 4.82”
MSRP: $175
Available: To be announced


Gerber Fastball MagnaCut

Gerber Fastball MagnaCut

Knife type: EDC folder
Blade length: 3”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: Flat
Blade finish: Stonewash
Blade pattern: Wharncliffe
Handle material: Aluminum
Lock type: Linerlock
Pocket clip: Tip up
Weight: 2.8 ozs.
Closed length: 4.1”
Knife to know: B.O.S.S. Tech (Balls of Stainless Steel technology) leverages a ball-bearing system providing Gerber’s smoothest, most consistent deployment to date; stainless steel balls reduce friction for seamless opening every time; the cage system is designed to keep the balls contained for stable performance over the long haul
MSRP: $159.99
Available: NOW

Gerber Fastball Liner Lock MagnaCut Knife Urban Blue

Gerber Fastball Liner Lock MagnaCut Knife Urban Blue

$174.99
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Buck Knives 791 Range Elite

Buck Knives 791 Range Elite

Knife type: Folder
Blade length: 3 3/8”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade grind: High-panel flat
Blade finish: Satin
Blade pattern: Drop point
Handle material: Anodized aluminum
Lock type: Crossbar
Pocket clip: Deep carry, reversible
Weight: 3.3 ozs.
Closed length: 4.5”
Special features: Spine gimping, thumb stud
MSRP: $275
Available: NOW

Buck Knives Buck 791 Range Elite Crossbar Lock Knife

Buck Knives Buck 791 Range Elite Crossbar Lock Knife

$275.00 $219.99
Prices accurate at time of publishing. Affiliate disclosure.

Check Out Other Months:

First Look: GiantMouse GMF1-MG

GiantMouse’s compact classic fixed-blade GMF1-MG updated with some top-notch materials.

GiantMouse has a knack for creating “giant” utility in small packages, and the company’s latest announcement proves they aren’t finished perfecting among its most recognizable designs. On January 22nd, the company will officially release the GMF1-MG, an evolution of the compact fixed blade that originally put the brand on the map for many EDC enthusiasts.

While the original GMF1 (the 2024 BLADE Magazine Imported Fixed Blade Of The Year®) was a skeletonized tool designed for minimalism, the MG (Micarta/Green) version enhances the user experience without sacrificing the design’s signature compact footprint.

GMF1-MG CPM MagnaCut

The most significant technical leap here is the move to a CPM MagnaCut blade. Finished in a clean satin, the super steel has become the industry benchmark for its ability to offer high-end toughness and edge retention while remaining nearly immune to corrosion. For a knife designed to live in a pocket or on a belt through all seasons, MagnaCut is the perfect choice to elevate the GMF1’s punch above its weight reputation.

Ergonomics And Personalization

GMF1M With Sheath

While the original GMF1 was often used with an aftermarket paracord wrap or custom scales, GiantMouse is now providing that grip straight from the factory. The GMF1-MG comes standard with Green Canvas Micarta scales, offering a warm, secure feel excelling in both dry and wet conditions.

In a move that will surely please the modding community, GiantMouse is also launching a line of interchangeable scales. Users can now personalize their GMF1 with options in burlap Micarta or even milled titanium, allowing the knife to shift from a rugged outdoor tool to a premium gentleman’s fixed blade in minutes.

Italian Made

Despite the upgrades, the GMF1-MG remains a masterclass in discreet carry. It stays lightweight and nimble, shipping with a handmade black leather sheath crafted in Italy. It’s a setup designed to challenge the traditional pocket folder for a spot in your daily rotation.

GMF1-MG Specs
Blade Length: 2.4″
Blade Thickness: 0.15″
Handle Length: 2.8″
Handle Thickness: 0.4″
Overall Length: 5.2″
Weight: 2.3 oz.
Blade Steel: CPM MagnaCut
Blade Finish: Satin
Handel Material: Green Canvas Micarta
Sheath: Black Leather
MSRP: $275

Read More Knife Buyer’s Guides:

New Knives: January 2026

From Ancient Inspiration to Modern Innovation: A First Look at the Year’s Most Anticipated Custom and Production Blades.

The new year kicks off with a formidable array of steel, ranging from primitive-inspired spears to high-tech tactical folders. This month’s selection highlights the incredible versatility of the modern cutlery world, showcasing the work of veteran masters with nearly four decades of experience alongside award-winning new makers. Whether you are looking for an ultra-premium custom Bowie for a collection or a hard-use MagnaCut automatic for daily carry, our January 2026 roundup proves that the industry’s innovation shows no signs of slowing down.


Jean-Pierre Potvin Short Spear

Jean-Pierre Potvin Short Spear

Blade length: 3.5”
Blade material: Damascus of 1084 carbon and 15N20 nickel-alloy steels
Blade grind: Flat
Handle: Ash w/burnt and oiled finish
Furniture: Bronze and copper
Overall length: 18.5”
Knife to know: Jean-Pierre Potvin created the texture for the blade steel by forging damascus and using a rotary tool to accentuate the details … he “wanted the texture to be similar to the flint spearheads that existed long ago”; he has been making knives for 36 years
Maker’s price for a similar piece: $2,500
Maker: Jean-Pierre Potvin (SharpByCoop image)


Grant Cunningham Trench knife

Grant Cunningham Trench knife

Blade length: 8”
Blade material: 52100 carbon steel
Blade grind: Double convex
Handle: Handmade brass knuckles, vulcanized fiber liners
S-guard: Brass
Overall length: 13”
Sheath: By Grey Leather Co.; black leather w/snap strap
Maker’s price for a similar knife: $1,250
Maker: Grant Cunningham, cunninghamcustomshop.com (Jocelyn Frasier image)


Rian Doudle Doudle Streetfighter Bowie

Rian Doudle Doudle Streetfighter Bowie

Blade length: 7.1”
Blade material: W’s pattern damascus in 1084 carbon and 15N20 nickel-alloy steels
Blade grind: Flat
Scales: Western myall, an Australian hardwood
Guard: Wrought iron
Overall length: 12.6”
Maker’s price for a similar knife: $1,200 at press-time exchange rate
Maker: Rian Doudle, Fallen Forge, fallenforge.com.au (Rod Hoare image)


Frank Edwards Push Dagger

Frank Edwards Push Dagger

Blade length: 3.25”
Blade material: Twist-pattern damascus of 1084 carbon and 15N20 nickel-alloy steels
Blade grind: Dagger
Scales: Carved interior mammoth ivory
Overall length: 6.5”
Maker’s price for a similar knife: $2,550
Maker: Frank Edwards (Jocelyn Frasier image)


SOG Knives Gambit XL

SOG Knives Gambit XL

Knife type: Fixed-blade karambit
Blade length: 4”
Blade steel: CRYO AUS-10A stainless
Blade @the thickest: 0.19”
Blade finish: Black stonewash
Blade finish: Hawkbill
Handle: Green paracord wrapped
Weight: 4.75 ozs.
Overall length: 8.75”
Sheath: Kydex® w/Safe-Lock clip
Country of origin: China
MSRP: $139.95
Company: SOG Knives, sogknives.com


APOC Wallace Small Puukko

APOC Wallace Small Puukko

Designer: Mike Wallace
Blade length: 3”
Blade material: D2 tool steel
Blade @thickest: 0.118”
Blade pattern: Drop point
Blade finish: Titanium coated
Scales: Black G-10
Weight: 3 ozs.
Overall length: 6.88”
Sheath: Kydex®; comes w/fire steel
Knife to know: Specs vary from piece to piece
Country of origin: China
MSRP: $82
Company: APOC, casiberia.com


CRKT Xolotl OTF

CRKT Xolotl OTF

Knife type: Out-the-front auto
Designer: Michael Rodriguez, U.S. Army Green Beret
Blade length: 3.5”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade @the thickest: 0.13”
Blade pattern: Spear point, ground on both edges
Blade finish: Titanium nitride
Scales: Aluminum
Opening mechanism: Dual action
Pocket clip: Sternum shaped, reversible
Weight: 3.2 ozs.
Closed length: 5.31”
Knife to know: An Aztec deity, Xolotl is “the guide of souls to the afterlife” … the handle has 21 ribs, one for each of the designer’s years in service
Country of origin: USA
MSRP: $324.99
Company: CRKT, crkt.com


Cold Steel Frenzy II

Cold Steel Frenzy II

Knife type: Tactical folder
Knife designer: Andrew Demko
Blade length: 5.5”
Blade steel: S35VN stainless
Blade polish: Satin
Scales: G-10
Pocket clip: Yes
Lock type: Tri-Ad®
Weight: 5.7 ozs.
Closed length: 6.75”
Country of origin: Taiwan
Knife to know: Design based on the kabutowari, an ancient Japanese design
MSRP: $239.99
Company: Cold Steel, coldsteel.com


TOPS Knives A-Klub

TOPS Knives A-Klub

Designer: Amanda Kaye
Blade length: 12.38”
Blade material: 1095 carbon steel
Rockwell hardness: 56-58 HRC
Blade @the thickest: 0.19”
Blade finish: Acid Rain
Scales: Green canvas Micarta®
Weight: 23.8 ozs.
Overall length: 17.88”
Sheath: Black Kydex®
Sheath clip: Dangler
Weight w/sheath: 33 ozs.
Country of origin: USA
Knife to know: The A-Klub is the first TOPS knife designed by a woman, Amanda Kay, a past participant on TV’s Naked and Afraid; design influenced by American Indian war clubs
MSRP: $409.95
Company: TOPS Knives, topsknives.com


Geoff Keyes Pirate Bowie

Geoff Keyes Pirate Bowie

Blade length: 16”
Blade material: 1080 carbon steel
Blade grind: Flat
Scales: Buffalo
Furniture: Integral bolster, steel and copper
Extras: Silk tassels handmade by Marianne George
Overall length: 22”
Maker’s price for a similar knife: $1,500
Maker: Geoff Keyes, 5elementsforge.com (Jocelyn Frasier image)


Taran Ma Sanctum

Taran Ma Sanctum

Knife type: Utility folder
Blade length: 3.5”
Blade steel: MagnaCut stainless
Blade openers: Blade oval and ambidextrous thumb studs
Scales: Titanium
Lock type: Framelock
Pocket clip: Yes
Closed length: 4.25”
Knife to know: Taran Ma has been making knives for 1 year
Maker’s price for a similar knife: Contact maker for information
Maker: Taran Ma (SharpByCoop image)


Josh Davis Sgian Dubh

Josh Davis Sgian Dubh

Blade length: 3.46”
Blade material: 80CrV2 carbon steel
Blade grind: Hollow
Blade thickness @ricasso: 0.118”
Blade @the widest: 1.8”
Scales: Ebony, mosaic pin, TruStone and brass
Overall length: 7.9”
Sheath: By the maker
Maker’s price for a similar knife: Contact maker for more info
Knife to know: Josh Davis won Best New Maker for his sgian dubh at the 2025 Adelaide Cutlers Expo; he is also a member of the Australian Knifemakers Guild
Maker: Josh Davis, CSC Knives (Rod Hoare image)


Check Out Other Months:

Advertisement

Must Read Articles

Read this before you make a knife

Knifemaking 101 – Read This Before You Make a Knife

  by Wayne Goddard My experience has taught me that there's nothing like digging in and getting started. I've often said the hardest part of the...
how to forge damascus steel

How to Forge Damascus

Advertisement
Advertisement